Post-Disaster Economic Recovery

The NADO Research Foundation has established this blog as an open forum for stakeholders of regional disaster mitigation and recovery. Posts will generally revolve around the economic impacts related to disaster recovery.

This blog is powered by the Resilient Regions initiative in partnership with the U.S. Economic Development Administration. To learn more about this program, please contact NADO program manger Mike Bellamente at mbellamente@nado.org.

Monday, May 24, 2010

For the Gulf Coast, a Long Road Ahead

Few disasters in history have played out as painfully slow as the BP Gulf oil leak, but the real unfortunate reality, 34 days in and counting, is how this disaster remains closer to the beginning of its life cycle than its end.


As accountability and solutions to the problem continue to be fumbled from one ineffective fix to the next, local fishermen and businesses observe helplessly as the damage to their livelihoods begins to unfurl. Similar to Exxon Valdez --previously the largest oil spill in U.S. history, but surprisingly not ranked in the top 30 worldwide-- it will require years if not decades before the economic (let alone environmental and psychological) healing of this event takes shape.

So far, this disaster has a much different appearance than, say, Hurricane Katrina which was characterized more by the rampant and swift devastation that occurred and the widespread loss of life. Keeping in mind the memories of the 11 men who died on Deepwater Horizon, the gusher in the Gulf continues to be more a test on the limits of a fragile aquatic ecosystem and the chain of life dependent upon its survival.

Environmental impacts aside, long-term economic recovery for the region depends on three things:

  1. The extent of damage to coastal areas once the well is finally capped

  2. The willingness of the affected communities and inhabitants to build back again

  3. The ability of responsible parties (BP, Halliburton, Transocean) and the federal government to make these communities financially whole

The Department of Commerce's Economic Development Administration (EDA) appears poised to take the lead on federal recovery assistance. Last week, EDA Assistant Secretary John Fernandez gave testimony to the U.S. Senate Committee for Environment and Public works in which he stated, "While in the short term, EDA regional staff is already providing technical assistance; our focus will remain on promoting long-term economic recovery and we will continue to work closely with the affected communities long after the cleanup is complete."

Other federal agencies are sure to follow suit in their pledge to assist the affected region --which will no doubt be a welcomed sentiment to business owners and residents of the Gulf-- the real test, however, comes when the final crutch is removed, and the wings of the region are once again ready to spread and fly on their own.

Monday, April 26, 2010

Call for Input - Disaster Resilience Guide 2.0

Last week NADO was invited to join the Regional Infrastructure Disaster Resilience (RIDR) Task Force to discuss possible upgrades to a 2006 disaster resilience guide. At first, I had my doubts that the document in question would be too urban-focused to be of value to our stakeholders.

Regional councils and economic development districts, being unique in form and purpose, require a disaster recovery strategy that is broad enough to encompass local governments and the adjoining business community, yet not too wide-angled to be effective in a recovery situation. Plus, with all the toolkits and online resources available today, disaster coordinators can often be daunted into using a guide that doesn't appropriately suit their needs.

To say that I was pleasantly surprised by the 2006 version of the document would be an understatement (turns out it's good enough for the Army Corps of Engineers to use, which is a pretty strong endorsement).

Entitled Regional Disaster Resilience: A Guide for Developing an Action Plan, the guide is a thorough, easily understood laundry list of short-, medium- and long-range action items across a multitude of focus areas (cyber threats, public-private partnerships, risk assessment, etc.).

Although not all the information is wholly suitable for regional councils, it can be easily massaged into a workable plan. Once I have a better understanding of the direction Version 2.0 of the document is taking, I'll be sure to pass it along.

In the mean-time, please read through the guide and submit any thoughts in the comment box below: http://www.tisp.org/index.cfm?cdid=10962&pid=10261

Cheers,
Mike Bellamente
Program Manager - Resilient Region Initiative
NADO Research Foundation
http://twitter.com/ResilientRegion


P.S. The NADO Research Foundation would like to recognize The Infrastructure Security Partnership (TISP) for all their great work in the realm of disaster resiliency: http://www.tisp.org/

Thursday, January 14, 2010

Recommendations for Improved Federal Response

As a result of last month's post-disaster recovery retreat in Cassopolis, Michigan (see Vegas of the North post), the International Economic Development Council, in partnership with NADO and BCLC, has drafted a series of recommendations on how our federal partners (FEMA, HUD, SBA, EDA, etc) could assist communities in taking a more proactive approach to economic recovery following a disaster event.

The formal paper will be available on our website shortly, but in the meantime here are a list of the recommendations proposed:

1. Establish a cognizant federal agency responsible for post-disaster economic recovery and provide appropriate resources.
2. Establish a special fund for economic recovery in the amount of $100 million to be kept on hand at the federally-designated agency for post-disaster economic recovery.
3. Remove the log-jam at the federal level in terms of the application review and use of federal funds as they relate to post-disaster economic recovery.
— Expedite the application process for federal funds
— Improve the consistency of requirements among federal programs
— Update federal criteria/regulations to meet post-disaster realities
4. Provide a trigger mechanism for waiving certain regulations on the use of federal funds in the unique situation of a disaster.
5. Consider adding “disaster recovery” as a fourth national objective to HUD’s CDBG Disaster Recovery Assistance program, OR consider redefining the third national objective so that eligible activities also meet economic recovery needs and can be used for a longer period of time relative to the size and scale of the disaster.
6. Change regulations to enable community organizations to use federal funds, including CDBG funds, for regional marketing and branding purposes.
7. If a community is planning to use federal dollars for a business loan program, ensure that program funds get de-federalized after initial use for maximum flexibility in the long-term financing of economic recovery.
8. Provide greater flexibility in the use of federal funds for increasing local capacity for economic recovery. This includes covering the salaries of local and state public employees, as well as the salaries of contracting nonprofit organizations, which are providing business recovery services and needed technical assistance.
9. Provide greater flexibility in the use of federal funds for funding economic impact assessments from an independent, non-biased source.
10. The federal government should provide more information on the availability of different federal programs both before and after a disaster to help local communities better navigate the federal system.
11. The federal government should develop a central repository of best practices in economic recovery as a reference tool for local communities.
12. Design federal inter-agency agreements (IAA), such as the IAA between HUD and FEMA, so that state and local government are part of those agreements and initial working relationships.
13. Federal agencies should proactively explain the specifics of duplication of benefits (DOB) and should develop better systems to deal with DOB.
14. Increase federal funds for non-traditional loan programs and expand the use of funds to include equity financing and loan loss that can leverage private resources for immediate small business recovery needs.
15. Increase the industrial development bonds (IDB) single-issuance capacity to $50 million and provide a guarantee by the federal government to provide further assistance to small businesses.
16. Consider tax incentives similar to programs in ARRA that benefit small businesses.
17. Consider financial incentives similar to programs in the Gulf Opportunity Zone Act and ARRA whereby businesses are provided federal tax incentives to reinvest in disaster-impacted areas.
18. Consider financial incentives similar to programs in New York after September 11th and in ARRA that help government agencies raise capital to redevelop infrastructure critical to the business community.
19. Consider providing federal funds for wage subsidy and job training programs to provide immediate, medium- and long-term assistance designed to retain and attract workers. There is a precedent of an effective program developed in NYC after September 11th attacks.
20. Consider pre-positioning temporary housing for certain industries that are identified by communities as being core economic recovery and/or growth engines in the wake of a disaster. Also, consider re-inventing FEMA/federal government temporary housing programs for administration by local government with a market-driven site selection process.

Tuesday, December 22, 2009

Vegas of the North

Being committed to your job often requires making compromises, making an occasional enemy and perhaps even making the odd trip to Cassopolis, Michigan in 12-degree, sub-arctic weather (thanks Stephen Jordan!).

Such was the case for 27 of the most respected minds in the disaster recovery business during a recent retreat to the Edward Lowe Foundation, December 15-17, 2009.

Similar to Las Vegas in the sense that kitty litter can be applied to many things, but has only one official purpose, the Edward Lowe Foundation creates a forum of camaraderie as a means of arriving at a desired goal.

The goal of this retreat was simple: Learn from past experiences to establish effective methods of rejuvenating small businesses following a disaster. Again, just picture Vegas with more snow, but without the lights, casinos, showgirls, etc...

With recovery expertise varying widely from Katrina, Gustav and Ike, to the Midwestern floods, California earthquakes and 9-11 (among others), the discussion was often intense, at times emotional and, suffice it to say, usually yielded more questions than answers. How can small businesses overcome exorbitant insurance premiums following a disaster? Should high-risk states develop a "rainy day" disaster fund to aid unforeseen recovery efforts? What incentives do small businesses have to write a disaster plan?

Of the organizations represented --- chambers of commerce, economic development councils/districts, regional councils of government, federal representatives of EDA and HUD ---all have been directly involved in restoring the economic and public health of a community following a disaster.

Below is just a brief example of some ideas that came up for better disaster preparation, reaction and recovery:
  • Information Dissemination -There needs to be a national clearinghouse for all disaster-related information including: state/federal funding resources, tool kits for recovery, best practices for cross-organizational communication, working with the media, etc.
  • Access to Capital - There needs to be a more immediate distribution of funds to small businesses which are more apt to fail without short-term disaster funding (within 0-6 months of disaster). Either a fast-track process similar to that of the IRS, or direct distribution from state/local governments
  • Training - There needs to be better training of the private, small business sector in terms of disaster planning and recovery - perhaps tied to tax incentives or financial aid. This could be the result of annual training provided by local chambers of commerce or economic development entities.
  • Regional Resilience - Working groups need to be created at the regional level to support continuous improvement of front-end disaster preparation and to better identify all the key players in the process (includes building relationship with state-level offices of federal government - FEMA/HUD/SBA/EDA)
  • Business Triage - Directly following a disaster there needs to be a better understanding of which businesses: a) aren't coming back no matter what b) could come back with immediate assistance or c) would come back if certain parameters justify a return.

Full disclosure: due to an oath akin to "what happens in Vegas, stays in Vegas", some valid points have been omitted from the above list. A more comprehensive list will be available in the coming months as part of ongoing discussion between retreat participants and other vested parties.

Please feel free to comment on these and additional issues related to small business disaster preparation and recovery in the comment box below.

Happy Holidays!

P.S. NADO would like to thank our partners at IEDC, BCLC and EDA for their contributions to this event. all the folks who braved the nightly campfires and, of course, those who attempted walking across it.

Monday, December 7, 2009

Disaster Recovery - Stakeholder Engagement

A disaster recovery working group has recently been developed featuring a partnership between DHS, HUD and the White House. The goal of this collaboration is to strengthen the ability of the federal government in assisting disaster-affected areas. As part of this effort, a list of several open ended questions have been posed to disaster recovery stakeholders nationwide.

NADO would like to hear your thoughts on these issues. Please respond to one or several of the questions using the comments section below.

- Are there clear phases in the disaster recovery process that are useful milestones?
- What features of Federal disaster recovery assistance are most important to you?
- How would you measure progress and what specific metrics should be considered for a successful disaster recovery?
- What are best practices in managing recovery from disasters?
- What are the appropriate state, local, and tribal, roles in leading disaster recovery efforts?
- How can the nonprofit and private sectors be better integrated into recovery?
- What are best practices for community recovery planning that incorporates public input?
- How can federal, state, and local disaster planning and recovery processes and programs be best coordinated?
- As disaster recovery is primarily a state and local leadership issue, what are best practices for the timing (including start and end) and form of federal assistance and coordination?
- What are the greatest capacity challenges that local and state governments face in disaster recovery and what are the best practices for increasing that capacity?
- What are best practices for marshaling Federal assistance -- both financial and professional support - to support state and local efforts to recover from a disaster, and how can we work together to better leverage existing Federal grant dollars?
- What unmet needs are common to most disasters that do not seem to be adequately addressed under the current systems and programs?
- What are best practices for integrating economic and environmental sustainability into recovery?
- What are best practices for integrating mitigation and resilience into recovery?

More information on these stakeholder questions can be found directly at: http://disasterrecoveryworkinggroup.gov/stakeholdersquestions.cfm